what would have been ifharry potter, Gryffindor's most famous graduate, sorted into Slytherin house at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry by the Sorting Hat? It's an intriguing question, sparked in large part by the fact that Harry was almost sorted into the wizarding school's green and silver house. Harry Potter was almost sent down a very different path, or at least one that starts from a dramatically different point.
After coming to Hogwarts for the first timeHarry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, the Sorting Hat tells Harry during the Sorting Ceremony that the decision is "very difficult" because he has so manySlytherin traitsas well as Gryffindor. In particular, the Sorting Hat mentions courage, intellect, talent and a thirst to prove himself, telling Harry that Slytherin would help him on his path to greatness. Just because Harry specifically asked not to be placed in Slytherin, the hat ends up in Gryffindor.
Related:Harry Potter: Deathly Hallows Deleted Scene Improved Draco's Redemption
But how different would the story of Harry Potter and the Second Wizarding War have been if the Sorting Hat had taken him to Slytherin? What if he hadn't asked to be sorted into Gryffindor and had instead joined Draco Malfoy, Crabbe and Goyle at Professor Severus Snape's house? And how would that have changed?End of the Harry Potter series?
Harry Potter would still have fought Lord Voldemort
In essence, Harry would still have been moved by the childhood trauma of losing his parents, Lily and James Potter, on that fateful night in Godric's Hollow. That was the turning point in his life until he received his letter to Hogwarts, and none of that would have changed with the Sorting ceremony. So it's incredibly unlikely that Harry would have worked hard to want to give up.lord voldemort, the murderer of his parents when he realized his rebirth and his intentions, regardless of whether or not they share a home.
not so muchharry potterBooks and film series from which Slytherin students are being removed.Battle of Hogwarts, despite the supposed message that not everyone is inherently evil. They are invited to join the fight against evil, but they all leave Hogwarts and apparently join Voldemort (as he himself tells Lucius Malfoy). The only Slytherins who seem to be fighting the Dark Lord are Professors Snape and Slughorn, and one of them in secret. No doubt Harry would have stayed and fought, as it was his fight, and McGonagall's rule that all Slytherins must leave is a fallacy - students over 16 who were willing to fight were welcome.
Crucially, Harry's affiliation with his house would not have changed his feelings towards Voldemort or his desire to overthrow him, despite and even despite the suggestion written in the structure of the books that Slytherin is the house of evil.Harry and Voldemort are related.. What would have changed were his methods leading up to the final confrontation and the impact it had on the composition of Slytherin.
Related:Why didn't Lord Voldemort know that Harry Potter was a Horcrux?
Harry Potter may have been lured by more dark magic
It seems logical to assume that a Hogwarts student, thanks to proximity to other like-minded students, will adopt even more the characteristics of the house in which he finds himself. In that sense, Harry Potter would be open to the influence of children brought into Slytherin by their cunning, self-preservation and ambition. These traits mean that Slytherins are more likely to stick to their necks and do whatever it takes to survive and thrive.
This could also have persuaded Harry Potter to use more dark magic in his long battle against Voldemort and his forces. at least until withGryffindor Propertiesand after being sorted into the house, Harry is willing to use Unforgivable Curses, unproven spells, and outright crime to further his goals; Add Slytherin influence and ambition to the crucible, and there's a recipe for more nefarious experiments. Harry may not have turned completely evil just by being in Slytherin, but his means to an end may have been clouded. And a closer connection to the Dark Arts could also mean that his connection to Voldemort was noted and triggered earlier.
Harry Potter would have imploded Slytherin House
While it seems unfair that an entire house has been written as fundamentally evil in the series, the proof seems to be in their actions, and the Slytherin traits bear this out. When Voldemort tells Lucius Malfoy that all Slytherins have joined him, it all but confirms that the anti-House bias is well deserved. But what if the leader of the fight against Voldemort was a Slytherin student?
The influence of Draco Malfoy, who was a prefect of Slytherin, and the perception that Severus Snape was in league with Lord Voldemort apparently led the students to think that they too were part of him.Voldemort's Death Eater. But if Harry Potter was a Slytherin and had made important friendships with other students, they would be more on his side than the Dark Lord. Harry was an immensely talented wizard, and the likes of Crabbe and Goyle would likely have been drawn to him, thanks to his traits of self-preservation through proximity.
Related:Harry Potter: Why was Dudley almost recast after Phoenix Command?
In short, the internal dynamics of Slytherin would have completely changed and there would likely have been a civil war in the house as Harry Potter loyalists clashed with the traditionally meaner students.
Harry Potter's relationship with Severus Snape may have changed
Harry Potter would always be afraid of him.Severo Snape: He is a formidable character and feared by his own Slytherin students. But as one of his own students, Harry may have had a much closer relationship with Snape, not least because selection into Slytherin would challenge the teacher's belief that Harry "Just like your father."Given its more favorable treatment, Harry may have excelled in Potions long before he had Snape's book, as he would have trained him himself.
If he knew the truth of his mission beforehandProfessor Snape's death? Probably not, as Dumbledore's plan with Harry has always been to keep him in the dark as much as possible, but the two would likely have a less cold relationship. This may also have affected the amount of time and effort Harry spent assuming Snape was the root of all evil and ignoring other useful clues.
It is still unlikely that Harry's relationship withlord voldemortwould have changed, however, because the Dark Lord was very motivated by his fear of the prophecy. While trying to recruit Lily and James Potter, their son still needed to be destroyed for Voldemort to prosper.
Related:Why is the number 7 everywhere in Harry Potter?
Harry Potter and Draco Malfoy would have been friends
It's a bit unthinkable in the first few books, but there's a real chance thatHarry e Draco Malfoythey would have become close friends. As a Slytherin, Harry would have spent very little time at Hogwarts outside of the classroom with Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger. He probably would have known Ron as the son of Order of the Phoenix members, but it's unlikely that Ron and Hermione would have become good friends without Harry as a bridge. It is much more likely that Harry's best friend is Draco.
Malfoy initially hates Harry for everything that should make him admire him: he sees him as arrogant, self-absorbed and privileged. Just because he is in Gryffindor and not Slytherin, these traits, which would ironically make him a great Slytherin, are despicable to Malfoy, who is not very confident. He sees Harry as something of a reflection of himself, and it is no coincidence that he initially offers Potter the chance to be his friend.The philosopher's Stone. Just because Malfoy is rude to Ron, he decides on the spot that he's not the type of person he wants to associate with. Had they been closer, and if not for Malfoy's treatment of Ron as a problem, the pair would have grown closer, especially knowing thatHarry Potter and Draco Malfoy are related.
So what impact would that have on Malfoy? In the end, aside from the conflicts within Slytherin, the greater House of Malfoy would have been torn apart, as Draco would likely have been drawn into Harry's adventures and misadventures and separated from his parents' intentions for him. He would become a "blood traitor", as his elite father put it, who could have completely disowned him (although his mother, Narcissa, was more on Draco's side).
Draco's story would be completely changed and he might even take on a heroic role in the story. Indeed, the idea of a Slytherin being born into the family of a prominent Death Eater and turning his back on his father and Lord Voldemort would have made as interesting a story asNeville LongbottomThe story of resilience and triumph over adversity. And Draco as a hero would also fit in with JK Rowling's main idea throughout the series that being in Slytherin house, or being born into any environment, does not determine your actions or your ending. Failing to deliver that kind of redemption arc for Draco, he really failed.harry potter general series.
What would happen if Harry was put in Slytherin? ›
Harry would have been internally conflicted if he had been Sorted into Slytherin. Although he still would have felt that Hogwarts was the only place he had ever belonged, he might have felt wary forming relationships with the children of Death Eaters.Would Harry have been sorted into Slytherin? ›
Harry Potter came very close to being sorted into Slytherin before he persuaded the Hat to sort him into Gryffindor. Yet the spectre of Slytherin haunted him for some time afterwards, becoming particularly potent in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, when he was rumoured to be the heir of Slytherin.Why was Harry Potter almost sorted into Slytherin? ›
Why was Harry Potter nearly sorted into the House of Slytherin by the Sorting Hat? Because Harry was ambitious, cunning and more than just a little devious.What would happen if Draco Malfoy was sorted into Gryffindor? ›
If Draco had been a Gryffindor, he still would have had parents strongly affiliated with Lord Voldemort and Bellatrix Lestrange as an aunt. Malfoy Manor would've still been a good base for Voldemort. Dumbledore would remain a major threat and Malfoy would have been in a good position to get close to him at school.Was there ever a good Slytherin? ›
Secondly, just because nearly all bad wizards are Slytherins doesn't mean all Slytherins are bad wizards. Severus Snape, Horace Slughorn, Andromeda Tonks, Narcissa Malfoy and Regulus Black were all Slytherin heroes in their own way, if you think about it.Why did Harry Potter not want to be in Slytherin? ›
At the core, Harry's reasons for not wanting to be in Slytherin were due to all the negative stories he had heard from Ron (his to-be best friend) and Hagrid (his first wizard friend). Besides, he had also had a distasteful first encounter with Draco (a Slytherin hopeful).